Grain Sorghum Hybrids for Grain 2021

Paul Price, Waltman, William F., Stephenson, Daniel O., Arceneaux, Kelly J., Roider, Christopher A., Harrison, Stephen A., Fromme, Daniel, Buckley, Blair, Brown, Sebe, Purvis, Myra, Padgett, Guy B., Ezell, Dustin, Parvej, Md Rasel, Groth, Donald E., Harrell, Dustin L., Kongchum, Manoch, Copes, Josh

Introduction

The performance of grain sorghum hybrids is annually evaluated in the official hybrid trials (OHTs) by LSU AgCenter researchers. The purpose of these trials is to provide Louisiana growers, seedsmen, county agents and consultants with unbiased performance data for commercial grain sorghum hybrids submitted for evaluation by private companies. Selection of superior hybrids that are well adapted for a given region is essential for maximizing yield and profit.

Hybrid Selection

Grain yield is usually considered the most important characteristic on which to base hybrid selection. The second characteristic to think about is the maturity group: early, medium/early, medium, medium/full and full. The selection of hybrid maturity is usually based on available water for the season, whether it be rainfall or irrigation. Hybrids that are high yielding in Louisiana are predominantly in medium or medium/full maturity groups. Additional hybrid selection criteria include lodging, weathering, plant height, test weight, heading date, stay-green, head exertion, panicle or head type, tolerance to sugarcane aphids, greenbug resistance, anthracnose resistance and other disease resistance.

To assist grain sorghum producers with hybrid selection, the LSU AgCenter conducts annual grain sorghum hybrid performance trials at several locations across the state. These trials provide grain sorghum producers with unbiased information on hybrid performance across different soil types and environmental conditions. During 2020, 10 hybrids were included in the seven trial locations in Alexandria, Baton Rouge, Bossier City, Crowley, St. Joseph, and Winnsboro (Tables 4-10). Agronomic details for each location are included in Table 1. Definitions for abbreviations are defined in Table 2.

Producers are encouraged to consult individual companies for hybrid recommendations and plant their own on-farm trials. Company data is not considered independent in the manner that public trials are conducted. However, these tests can still be an excellent source of information, particularly for a comparison of yields among hybrids from the same company.

Please review the results from all trials that are relevant to your farming location and look for hybrids that have desirable, consistent results over years and locations. Do not rely on only one source of hybrid performance information. Plant two or more hybrids to mitigate risk. Place more value on replicated trials when comparing to strip trials.

Procedures

The experimental design at each location was a randomized complete block design with four or five replications. Analyses of variance and least-significant differences (LSD) were calculated only if differences existed at the 90% confidence level. If differences were significant, an LSD at the 10% probability level was calculated. If the LSD (0.10) for yield in a trial is 10 bushels per acre, there is a 10% chance that two hybrids with a reported yield difference of 10 bushels per acre are genetically equal and a 90% probability they have a difference in genetic potential in that particular environment. LSD values are influenced by how well soil fertility, stand establishment, plot length, harvest efficiency and other variables are controlled and by the number of replications for each hybrid. The letters NS are used in the text and tables to indicate lack of significance (not significantly different) at the 10% probability level. The coefficient of variation (CV) reflects the magnitude of experimental error (random variation not accounted for by hybrids and replications) in relation to the trial mean. A high CV means that relative differences among hybrids were not consistent among replications, which reduces the precision of the test.

Yield data for 2020 across locations is summarized in Table 3. Individual location summaries are located in Tables 4 through 10. Also, participating seed companies and their hybrid entries are listed in Table 3.

Planting Date

Plant grain sorghum as early as possible during the recommended planting date range. In south Louisiana, the recommended planting range is between April 1 and May 1. In north Louisiana, the range typically is between April 15 and May 15. Early planting is one of the most important cultural practices a producer can adopt to maximize grain sorghum yields because yields decrease progressively with later planting dates. The five-day average soil temperature should be at least 60 degrees Fahrenheit at the 2-inch depth, although an ideal temperature for quick germination and establishment of grain sorghum is near 65 degrees Fahrenheit. The minimum soil temperature for germination and emergence of sorghum is about 55 degrees Fahrenheit, but slow growth should be expected. In addition, a later-planted crop will likely be vulnerable to greater disease and insect pressure, particularly sorghum midge and sugarcane aphid. After June 15, it is less risky to plant soybeans than grain sorghum.

Seeding Rate and Depth

Grain sorghum should be planted at a rate of approximately 75,000 seeds per acre. This is equivalent to five to six seeds per row foot on 40-inch centers, four to five on 30-to-36-inch centers and three to four on 20-inch centers. If rows are 10 inches or less, three seeds per row foot should be adequate. Seed should be planted in adequate moisture no deeper than 2 inches. Optimum depth ranges from ¾ to 1 ½ inches deep.

Sorghum seed varies in size from 12,000 (38 grams per 1,000 seed) to 18,000 (25 grams per 1,000 seed) seeds per pound. If using pounds per acre to plant, growers should be aware that populations can vary greatly (Table 11). Consequently, seeding rates should be based on seed per acre and not pounds per acre. Seed number per pound will be stated on the seed bag tag.

Row Spacing

Sorghum responds positively to narrow row spacing (30 inches or less). Plants are more efficient when each plant is given space to intercept sunlight and competition from other plants is minimized. In addition, narrow rows promote shading of the soil surface, which reduces evaporation losses and weed competition.

Predicting Sorghum Development Based on Air Temperature

Grain sorghum growth stages can be determined from planting through black layer. The duration of each growth stage is closely correlated to air temperature and hybrid maturity group (Table 12). We know that daily minimum and maximum temperatures vary from year to year and between locations. Consequently, the number of calendar days from planting to emergence, panicle initiation, flowering and black-layer varies and is not a good indication of crop developmental stages. As a result, thermal time more reliably estimates crop development than the number of calendar days. It is estimated as the cumulative number of growing degree units (GDU) between growth stages, for example, from planting to emergence, to panicle initiation and so forth. For grain sorghum, GDUs accumulated each day are calculated as follows:

formulapng

The base temperature or lower temperature limit of sorghum development is 50 degrees Fahrenheit, while the upper limit is 100 degrees Fahrenheit. Air temperatures greater than 100 degrees Fahrenheit are entered as 100 degrees Fahrenheit, and temperatures less than 50 degrees Fahrenheit are entered as 50 degrees Fahrenheit.

Fertility

Soil testing is the foundation of a sound fertility program. This is the only way to apply soil amendments (i.e., lime and fertilizers) correctly and efficiently. Proper fertility is critical for optimizing grain sorghum yields. The vast majority of grain sorghum fields will require the addition of fertilizer.

The estimated uptake of nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium and sulfur by grain sorghum (125 bu/A) is presented in Table 13. The values presented are not the amount of nutrients that need to be applied, but rather the total uptake by the grain sorghum crop from soil, fertilizer and other sources.

Soil pH

Soil pH affects the availability of nutrients. The optimal soil pH for grain sorghum ranges from 5.8 to 6.5. Continued cultivation and the use of chemical fertilizers, especially those containing ammonium and sulfur, tend to decrease soil pH over time. Irrigation with water high in calcium carbonate, on the other hand, tends to increase soil pH.

Soil samples should be collected and checked for the degree of acidity or alkalinity. Lime is generally recommended at pH values below 6.1, and general guidelines to raise pH are detailed in Table 14. Soil texture and buffer capacity are required for an accurate estimate of lime requirements. If lime is needed, applications should occur during the fall to provide enough time for it to react with the soil.

The relative neutralizing value (RNV) of lime affects the application amount. This value is based on the individual material fineness and calcium carbonate equivalent (CCE), which is the amount of pure calcium carbonate to which the selected material corresponds, with finer materials reacting more quickly than coarse materials. A liming material with a CCE of 100 is “stronger” than one with a CCE of 90. Consequently, less volume of the stronger material would be needed to increase the pH of a given soil.

Nitrogen

Nitrogen can be applied before or at planting, and split applications can be used. Apply nitrogen in a split application with 50% to 75% applied before or at planting and the balance no later than the 6- to 8-leaf stage. All of the required nitrogen can be applied pre-plant or at planting, but this increases the risk of fertilizer burn on seedlings and nitrogen loss from leaching or volatilization. Nitrogen should be applied between 100 to 125 or 125 to 150 pounds per acre on upland and alluvial soils, respectively. A rough rule of thumb is to apply 1.12 pounds of actual nitrogen for each bushel of grain sorghum produced.

Phosphorus

Grain sorghum utilizes phosphorus early during the growth period, so this nutrient should be applied pre-plant or at planting (Table 15). Soil testing is recommended to determine appropriate levels for each field, but most soils require 40 to 60 pounds of P2O5 per acre. Band applications of phosphorus will increase efficiency in very acidic or alkaline soils. Also, starter fertilizers can be beneficial for soils that have a high pH or have low phosphorus levels.

Sulfur

A grain sorghum crop (125 bu/A) takes up about 23 pounds per acre sulfur with about 8 pounds per acre removed in the grain at harvest. When a soil test is utilized to determine if sulfur is needed, values of less than 12 ppm (Mehlich 3 extraction) suggest that additional sulfur may be needed. The typical recommended rate of sulfur is 20 pounds per acre in the sulfate form.

Zinc

Zinc was one of the first micronutrients recognized as essential for plants and the most common that limits yields. Although zinc is required in small amounts, high yields are impossible without it. If zinc is lower than 1 ppm, apply 10 pounds per acre of zinc in a soluble form, such as zinc sulfate or zinc chelate (Table 17). Among the inorganic zinc sources on the market, the most common sources are sulfates, oxides and oxysulfates. Zinc sulfate and zinc chelates essentially are 100% water-soluble, while zinc oxides essentially are insoluble in a single crop season and thus unavailable to the crop to be planted. Oxysulfates are a mixture of sulfates and oxides, with varying proportions of sulfates and oxides and different solubility levels (0.7% to 98.3%). The effectiveness of these can be highly variable, depending on solubility. Low solubility materials may have some value in a long-term buildup program, but when immediate results are the goal, highly soluble fertilizers are the best choices. For acceptable in-season efficacy, a zinc-fertilizer source should be at least 50% water-soluble. If a soil test shows zinc is between 1 and 2.25 ppm, apply 5 pounds of zinc per acre when broadcasting. Less is needed if using a banded application.

Pest Control

Weeds compete with grain sorghum for light, nutrients and soil moisture, thus reducing yield and grain quality. For each inch of soil moisture used by weeds, 5 to 7 bushels per acre of grain yield can be lost. Weeds also may harbor insects and diseases that could potentially impact yield and quality. The most critical period for weed control is the first four weeks after planting. If weeds are controlled during this time and maintained throughout the season, little reduction in grain sorghum yield is expected. However, weed escapes can be a major yield threat and can interfere with harvest. Herbicides commonly used for weed control in grain sorghum can be found in the 2020 Louisiana Suggested Chemical Weed Management Guide. Information concerning proper herbicide rates, application timings and other details also can be found within the guide. The Insect Pest Management Guide and Plant Disease Management Guide also are available to guide management decisions.

Water

Grain sorghum has reputation for drought tolerance, which makes it a good choice for dryland situations. A sorghum crop that receives 21 inches of usable water during the growing season will use 6 to 8 inches to produce the head, while the other 13 to 15 inches will produce approximately 100 bushels of grain per acre. Moisture stress early in the season will limit head size (number of seeds per head) and delay maturity. If stress occurs later in the season, the seed size is greatly reduced. The number of heads is not affected by moisture stress unless drought is severe enough to prevent head formation.

During the seedling stage, only a small amount of moisture in the soil surface is required to establish the crop. More moisture is lost during this stage through evaporation from the soil surface than through plant uptake. Water conserving practices, such as residue management, timely planting for quick establishment, narrow row spacing and weed control, will minimize soil moisture losses.

About 30 to 35 days after emergence, five to six true leaves are visible, and the plant begins rapid growth. Nearly half of the total seasonal water will be used during this stage prior to heading. The most critical period for water availability for sorghum begins about one week before head emergence, or boot stage, and continues through two weeks past flowering (Figure 1). Sorghum plants require adequate soil moisture during this period for maximum yields. Optimum soil moisture prior to boots stage will assure the highest potential seed set. The actual seed number and seed size will be dependent upon the availability of soil moisture following flowering. Moisture demand drops quickly after the grain has reached soft-dough stage. This combined drop in moisture demand, natural drought tolerance and the extensive root system of sorghum generally make late irrigations unprofitable.

water usage graphicjpg

Harvest Aids

In Louisiana, grain sorghum producers may consider harvest aids, particularly glyphosate, to manage sorghum dry down and harvest for several reasons. Currently, sodium chlorate and glyphosate are labeled for application in grain sorghum for several reasons, including:

  • Easier threshing.
  • Drying out the late-emerging head and nonproductive sucker-head tillers that otherwise could delay harvest.
  • Reducing differences in harvest maturity across a field that has different soil types.
  • Killing the sorghum plant, which reduces moisture and nutrient loss from the soil.
  • Hastening the decay of the crown, which could interfere with planting the following year.
  • Accelerating harvest to meet a delivery or pricing deadline.
  • Reducing the presence of moist, weedy material in the grain.

On a cautionary note, applying harvest aids to sorghum fields with stalk or charcoal rot can increase lodging if prompt harvest does not occur.

Applications should not be made prior to black layer and if seed moisture is above 30%, or grain yields will be reduced. Furthermore, if a harvest aid is applied at black layer, harvest should occur in the next 7 to 10 days.

Determining Harvest Losses

As a rule of thumb, 17 to 20 kernels per square foot are equivalent to 1 bushel per acre. To aid in determining losses, a 1-square-foot frame may be constructed from heavy wire. It is recommended to take at least three ground counts at each location. Also, when making ground counts for kernels, look for lost heads. One 10-inch head per 10-foot area is approximately 1 bushel per acre.

Ratooning

As a member of the grass family, sorghum has a panicle-type inflorescence and tillering characteristics that make it able to regenerate the above-ground portion of the plant. This characteristic allows producers to seek a second grain crop within the same growing season. Ratooning practices begin with shredding the sorghum stalks down. The decision to ratoon is made only after 5 to 6 inches of regrowth is observed, which is then followed by 40 to 60 pounds of nitrogen. One can usually plan on the ratoon crop to yield from one-quarter to one-third of the main grain crop. A great ratoon crop seldom follows a poor main crop. Damage and feeding by birds are the most devastating problems. Blackbirds have deterred many producers from sorghum ratooning.

*Please see PDF for all tables.

12/17/2020 5:39:02 PM
Rate This Article:

Have a question or comment about the information on this page?

Innovate . Educate . Improve Lives

The LSU AgCenter and the LSU College of Agriculture

Top